it's probably no surprise that you can get better food on the mainland, but the offerings at rectory café aren't bad either. i think, however, one has to choose carefully. the menu is a bit hit-and-miss imho. the grilled calamari is great. the taco salad is not. the burger is decent.
value is reasonable. service is friendly, a touch slow though.
all that being said, it's the patio that's breathtaking - like an oasis within an oasis. the most idyllic place for a beer after a bike ride or to pass the afternoon with a book and some tea.