More of a 4.5. We visited on a Friday evening (around 8?) and did not have to wait for a table, which was nice. They have a nice variety of beers and wines to choose from. We decided to share the pesto pizza and the brisket Mac and cheese. They were served nice and hot. Delicious! The service was very attentive. We wish we could have tried dessert but we were too full! The only reason they do not get 5 stars is because of the restaurant seating options. Be advised if you choose bar seating, you may end up sitting in front of the brick oven which is very hot! You could feel the heat from the oven as soon as you walk in.