Fleming's has very good steaks. They are not the best in Madison as some people claim, that honor goes to the Tornado Club.
I had the Ribeye, and it was delicious, great flavor and cooked a perfect medium rare just as I requested. The ribeye was slightly over salted though, but the flavor made that barely noticeable. The sides are served family style which is something I like. The Fleming's potatoes are amazing(Potatoes with cheese, cream, and jalepeno pieces) and the grilled asparagus was flawless.
4 and a half stars, but since that isn't a rating they get rounded down and not up.