3.5 stars.
We tried Fenwick's because of the great reviews and it was pretty good. I had a barbecue chicken breast (that was more like an ordinary chicken breast because I didn't taste or see any barbecue), with fries. It was good, but nothing particularly extraordinary about it. I liked that it wasn't too thick or dry. My husband had a California burger I believe. He liked it but I didn't taste it because it had guacamole all over it and I don't eat guacamole. I tasted my daughter's well-done London broil and it was shoe-leather tough! She said she liked it but I'm not sure how. I could hardly chew it. But....to each his own I guess.
All in all, the place is cozy and comfortable for a lunch date and I liked what I had. I wasn't blown away or anything, and I find them to be a bit pricey. Some of their other menu items might be more impressive. Perhaps I'd go back in the future to try something different.