After driving past this restaurant several times my husband and I decided to stop for dinner one evening. The outside of this restaurant along with the "bistro" on their sign fooled us into thinking this was a casual eatery so we arrived wearing jeans and sweatshirts and felt TERRIBLY underdressed. This is definitely a more upscale place than it appears from the outside.
That said, we stayed to eat and ordered the cheese curds appetizer (very tasty), Rue 251 steak with their "famous" gratin potatoes, and the Dayboat Scallops. The food was good but my steak was WAY overdone - I ordered it medium well and it was burnt. The potatoes had a terrific flavor and the portion was huge but there was a crunch in the middle that indicated they weren't fully cooked. The scallops were the star of our table and so well-cooked and delicious but the portion was very small, especially for the price. Our total bill came to nearly $80 just for food as we both ordered water to drink.
Service was fantastic and ambiance was wonderful but I doubt we'll dine here again. Too expensive for a meal that didn't deliver.