I brought my dad to this place, and I cannot stress enough how picky of a diner he is. ESPECIALLY when it comes to Italian food. He makes his own meatballs and sauce at home and I'm usually afraid to bring him out because he is so open with his distaste, and often sends things back.
He had the spaghetti with meatballs ribs and sausage and he was blown away at how good it was. I had the Rodfather and loved it too. We were both really full after, I'm actually really surprised that there are other reviews about the size being too small.
The salad that came with the sandwich was awesome, it wasn't your basic garden salad, it had kale and what i think were homemade pickled radishes? Anyway it was great, I might even go back just to get that salad. Another thing that will get me to go back is the homemade soda!!! it's awesome and made with REAL ingredients (i.e. the gingerale had actual pieces of ginger).
Most importantly, the staff is really genuinely nice and attentive. No matter how good the food is, if people are rude, I will never go back.
I highly recommend this place if you are looking for a really good, reasonably priced home-made meal.
Cost for 2 people: 29$