I feel like I need to defend Joe's because of the many great times getting pizza from them. I'm a New Yorker to the bone and this place looks like an NY Pizzeria that you get slices in or order a regular or pie with toppings. Like most places they have their pizza around $3 to $4 per slice which at this point is the going rate in most of the country.
Order slices of pizza here, they will put it in the oven and take it out when it's hot. Then you pay. It's pretty simple concept.
Yes they have salads and sandwiches which I have never had but understand their specialty is delicious pizza by the slice. If you really want a salad you should go somewhere else.
I have gotten delivery once during the day and the pizza was great and quickly delivered. But those of you ordering drunk food after midnight I just don't know what you expect. Where else around Old Town is open past the bars? If you're mad about the price ask about it before you agree on ordering the food.