They can easily be a 5. The food was wonderful - that is a 5 - creative, tasty, good selection. The atmosphere is a 3. The bar is great but it is very small and hard to get a seat at so you are then left with the back patio or basement - not a good vibe at all. They need to work with a good restaurant decorator to remodel so that is is good outdoor spot and doesn't feel like a cave or cold outdoor patio. If they can pull that off I will give them a 5. But great food and we will come back and try to get a bar seat next time.