We've been to this particular location several times now and it's never been a let down! Went this weekend while they were having an Art Show in the area and cooled off and enjoyed the people watching after walking around for a couple of hours. They have a good variety of flavors for just about every person's taste and they also share the space with a pizzeria that looks like they serve up some pretty tasty food, although we haven't tried that out just yet.
There is also a bar upstairs that looks like a new addition to the space and would be worth a look when we are back in old town. We will for sure be revisiting them for gelato anyways!