If I could give it a 3.5 I would, based on my NY Chicken sandwich and previous trips to this restaurant where I've also had great pizza and grinders.
This is a counter order restaurant and casually decorated and great for families! Many take out orders came and went while we dined and there was a steady flow of customers in and out of the cozy dining area. Service was okay, didn't blow us away.
My date ordered cheese pizza and spaghetti and was reasonably pleased with both. Based on my previous trips I'd dine here again, probably getting the Sicilian pizza again, which I loved the last time!
Overall an ok experience...family owned and a good ol' home town Italian place