Overall summary: Average at best with some notable flaws, but with some work could be good. I'm willing to eat there again if things improve.
The Good:
Prices are decent.
Pizzas are handmade, and made in front of you Subway style.
Nice, classic pizzeria decor.
Friendly staff.
Caesar salad is good, albeit the large isn't really large.
The Bad:
The smoked salmon pizza we got was....weird. It also had too much garlic, dough was a little soft, and the rest of the flavors were muted from the garlic.
The lighting is uneven. Half of it is soft white bulbs and the other half is daylight bulbs. Its a small thing, but throws the ambiance off.
We weren't given plates to eat our pizza on, or to share our salad. We had to eat on napkins.
The utensil and condiment basket only had one fork, and the olive oil dispenser was empty. Went to some other tables to grab some and the first three I checked didn't have any either.
They forgot about the free canoli we asked for through the Yelp promotion.