I visited the Middleton location about a month ago and was pretty disappointed. I had tried some cupcakes from the downtown location that a friend had shared with me and they were amazing. The shop is adorable and at first glance, you will want to buy everything! However, the almond raspberry cupcakes and cinnamon rolls I had from the Middleton location were extremely dry and overcooked to the point that they had shrunken in their wrappers. Way overpriced for a tiny, dry cupcake. The flavors were interesting, so I would definitely try again. I was also in kind of a hurry and the girl at the counter who was clearly not busy ignored me when I tried to get her attention during the first 5 minutes I was there, then took a long phone call and continued to ignore me during the call. It took her a long time to finally take my order.
Their only redemption was the Decadent Chocolate cupcake and Salted Caramel Brownies I tried. Those were cooked well and lived up to their names.