The donuts are pretty okay. They are very dense, full of flavor, and not toooo sweet. If you like light and airy then this may not be your joint.
We hit up City Girl on a Saturday around 11am and they had just about sold out of everything so we were limited to: lemon poppyseed, chocolate glaze, maple stick, and cannoli stick. The stick donuts were tiny. Like REAL SMALL. Half a dozen set us back almost $16. They were really good, and fresh. Not sure if they were worth the $16.... except for a special occasion?
I don't know, I'm conflicted. The donuts were decent but that's a lot of money for 6 donuts!!! The spot is cute and urban. Parking kind of sucked. Would I go back? Yes. I would go earlier than 11am on a weekend to have prime picking. Only then so I think I could be non biased. In the meantime, staff was friendly, the shop was cozy, and the donuts were good in small doses.