Went here in August with the Supper Club for a 6:30pm dinner. This place was hard to find as it's located in a residential area. I passed it several times because the exterior doesn't look like your typical restaurant facade - and there is a school down the block! I must admit, I yelled at my GPS several times for seemingly directing me to the "wrong" place each time "she" said "destination!" - ha! I got a prime parking spot in the small lot next to the restaurant (there is a larger lot across the street).
We were a group of five and were seated in less than 15 minutes. The interior is rustic and for some reason reminded me of a log cabin in Canada - go figure. This is not a large place, so this and the dim lighting added to the rustic and cozy ambiance - a good place for a date.
Our waiter was very attentive and met every need. We ordered two bottles of wine and the following food items: 1) cheese curds; 2) rosemary goat cheese bruschetta; 3) mac and cheese; 4) summer gnocchi; and 5) veal meatloaf.
With the exception of the bruschetta, my impression of everything we tasted was "Wow!" The cheese curds had just the right balance of creaminess from the cheese and saltiness - no sauce needed! The mac and cheese was unlike any I've tasted, not made with typical cheddar but a mix of white cheeses. The veal meatloaf was very flavorful and moist. My fave is the summer gnocchi - I remember thinking this was the best gnocchi I've had thus far. The gnocchi had the appearance of being pan-seared, and the tomatoes and basil really added to the "summer" and fresh taste.
We spent a good two hours here, and although our bill for the food and bottles of wine came to under $100, we paid $150 - our waiter even told us we paid too much! lol A place that provides great food, service and ambiance deserves the extra $$.