Very disappointing -- and I've been to this place numerous times and used to really enjoy it.
The atmosphere was still awesome, the wait staff attentive and friendly, and the food delicious.
So why only one star?
My pasta dinner was so small we had to go for a second dinner to another pub afterwards.
I had the stuffed pasta in a tomato sauce. Really good, but at $15, and listed as an entrée I expected it to be bigger than an appetizer.
My girlfriend had the roast beef and risotto which was succulent and tender, and slightly more filling. But still an incredibly small portion.
The Red Tomato's menu lists more shareable options than entrées so perhaps that is what they are known for.
However, if you order something for dinner that is suppose to be an entrée, then it should be filling.
Those just wanting a good drink and some ambiance will enjoy the restaurant in Toronto's Entertainment District. Just go someplace else for food, unless you want to leave hungry.