First things first, I was very much on the fence between 4 and 5 stars.
The pizza was simply AMAZING. The crackling crispy crust was the best I've had in Charlotte. All the ingredients (Basil, Tomato, Mozzarella) were great.
Beer selection was great.
Gelato was delicous
One suggestion for improvement: Off the shelf pizzas (picking out the toppings myself is stressful; give me some options - even if they're only a starting point.)
Also, piece-mealing the topics seemed to result in a pricier pizza than I'd expected.