This place has been around for so long! I just googled it and apparently it's been around since the 90's which makes sense. Although I have been coming here on and off since I was a kid, I cannot correlate my persistent visits to the taste/value of Frankie Tomatto's AYCE italian food. The food here is okay but is not cooked very well (ie. pasta over done, flavors not particularly unique nor authentic). The price is also pretty steep for a buffet that doesn't serve good food. If you're not super picky with food, the atmosphere is good for celebrations: for birthdays they do a whole song complete with a little paper wreath crown + a tomato balloon; and who doesn't love a buffet with friends (complete with italian decorations)?
Random tip: The best thing they serve are the beef short ribs! Don't miss out on that in an otherwise unremarkable menu.