I was a bit hesitant to try Nick's after reading some of the reviews, but was quite impressed with the meal I recently had there. We went on a Friday after work for a casual date night, and I ordered the blackened steak, my date had the steak neptune. We both thought the food's taste and quality was great. I'd say the menu was a bit lacking with selection, but then again, it's a steak and pizza place.
As everyone mentioned, it was quite busy there, but we found a booth in the lounge. The decor isn't anything to write home about, but I came for a great meal and got it!