Decided to give it another chance (no cold sore sightings). Had the Club Supreme Mike's Way. The sub was good and the restaurant is clean. Overheard one of the staff apologize to a couple for not having a chance to clear the table where they wanted to sit.
If subs are your thing, Jersey Mike's is good when compared to the Subway's and Blimpie's of the world.
For me, favorite subs I've had are from a little sub shop in the little college town of Slippery Rock, Pennsylvania.