We had dinner here in a group of 4 and it was a pretty good experience. I ordered one of their burgers with fries and, although it wasn't quite as good as some of the burgers from the classic pubs in downtown Madison, it wasn't a bad burger at all. I also order their fresh-squeezed orange juice and it was as fresh and as good as advertised. To be honest though, I was a little underwhelmed with their pies. Maybe it was because they hype them up so much that my expectations going in were too high but I just wasn't blown away by any of the 4 different ones that we ordered. Still, the atmosphere is really nice and the prices and portions are reasonable, so I'd definitely come here again and give a different pie another try.