There's something about BBQ that makes a man feel like a man. Meaty, saucy, fatty, crunchy, messy - the proper pig brought out my inner cave man. ROAR. I ordered the combo with 2 meats (brisket + pulled pork) and 1 side (potato salad).
The meats were tender, melt in your mouth. I really enjoyed the house bbq sauce - a bit thicker than Mabel's - and slathered onto my meats to provide the necessary lubrication to devour it in a matter of minutes. The side potato salad was also tasty - definitely not as good as Mabel's - but it had an interesting take with a chipotle-esque mayo that added a bit more flavor than expected.
The Proper Pig is a good 2nd piggy to Mabel's in terms of the Cleveland BBQ scene. Will definitely go back especially for the comparative price - $12 for the combo versus ~$20+ for something similar at Mabel's.