I'm not going to lie- I'm a hard woman to impress with coffee. It's good, definitely not burnt or weak, and more flavorful than Starbucks. Did it blow my mind? No. I did get a raspberry thumbprint cookie which was REALLY good though, and all of their baked items looked delicious. I highly recommend getting something with your coffee, even if you have to eat it later.
The atmosphere was as described - 'cozy' and with lots of character if not a whole lot of places to stand while waiting for your drink. It is a good place to sit and chat, as there is lots of seating alcoves. It was little crowded when I went (Thursday afternoon), but the staff had the flow down and the wait wasn't bad.
I won't be driving cross town just to get a cup though, but I might stop in again if I'm in the area.