Deeeelicious!
First, the upstairs is a pretty cool area to sit and wait for a table. When we arrived we realized we forgot to make reservations (sigh) and were forced to wait around for an hour. But luckily they have a bar and seating area upstairs where you can order drinks and appetizers while you wait! I had wine, my boyfriend had beer and we of course ordered some cheese curds. They are so good, some of the best in Madison! Perfectly seasoned and still gooey inside.
When we were finally seated, I wasn't as hungry as I thought I'd be (probably from eating almost all of the curds) so I ordered a soup and salad combo. You get a lot of food for a cheap price ($6.99). The soup was a creamy tomato soup and the salad is a simple tossed salad with lots of feta. Both were yummy, I really enjoyed the soup though and I could have eaten an entire bowl of it. My boyfriend had the Craftsman burger and really enjoyed it. Service was great, too.
We will be back, next time with reservations!