Not bad but not great. The problem I have with places claiming to have "the best of..." is that they may only be the best if no other is around. Their Sicilian is mostly dough. They claim coming from Chicago that this is the taste they wanted to recreate and I definitely applaud them for wanting to bring that taste here to AZ. However, with a Lou Malnadi's here, they may want to change their recipe. Unfortunately there is a lack of REALLY good pizza places in the Surprise area. My best recommendation for either thick or thin, Sicilian or regular crust goes to NYPD Pizza nearby.