I wish I could break the review down to two parts - "The Pizza" and "The Rest"
I have been here several times and their pizza is awesome. I personally like the "New York" pizza and have never been disappointed.
I have also had the balsamic chicken salad a few times and it is also good, but not as good on the good scale as the pizza.
Where they fall short, starters and appetizers. Because the individual pizza is filling, I usually stay away from the appetizers and starter items. However, today I was in the mood for something new. It was raining so I figured it was a good soup day. I ordered Lobster Bisque - VERY tasty but $8 bucks for a small sized bowl. I also thought some of the parmesan crusted artichokes sounded good. Nope, they were not good and they were $10 for basically one artichoke heart cut into 4 pieces. I felt a little violated here.
Service is always adequate - never bad but never anything above and beyond and that's ok with me too.
I would recommend this place for the pizza and because it's very good, I gave the 4 stars. I would have only given 3 stars otherwise.