The Cage rules. I'll agree with Zoe P 100% -- screw the cheesy themed clubs and bars, and get down to it at the Cage. The only "frills" it has is an online jukebox and some video poker that looks like it's been there since the 80s.
The food is greasy and cheap and fabulous with a beer. Prices are great on pitchers, and the selection is not too bad. Weeknights are actually better here -- on weekends you better get in and get a table early if you want to sit.