According to a friend who is a local, Gibby's is an "institution." It is very old and very rustic, a classic steakhouse.
I'm not a big steak eater so I ordered the Chicken Kiev. This was the first time I ever ordered this dish and the waitress had told me to be careful but I didn't quite catch on. My first cut through the chicken caused hot liquid butter to squirt out all over my brand new top. I was a mess! Our waitress, Nadia, was very nice and brought me some club soda. You live and you learn!
The chicken was delicious, even after all that. My husband and our friend both enjoyed their steaks. We all shared the creme brûlée for dessert which was good, but nothing to write home about.
I liked this place but since steakhouses are not really my thing, I will give it four stars.