J&M has been my go-to leather shoe store for quite a while now. While I was deeply saddened the PV Mall location closed, I was lucky to see it wasn't much more of a drive to the Fashion Square location.
I actually think it's a little bigger too. Mostly shoes along the walls, but you have upper clothing, plus some socks, belts and maybe scarves.They have a wide variety from dress to casual styles. I will say it's either 99% or 100% men's selection, even though they do have a women's line you can see sometimes in other stores or online. But regardless, I stick because the shoes are a quality product that has always lasted for me.
My only caveat is that somehow I've never found my size in stock - my feet are borderline large but definitely wide. Of course I can always ship free to my house in 4-6 days and return in store, but that's kind of inconvenient when you're window shopping in a mall. Whether it's the PV location or even a random J&M at the mall, I've only failed to find my size in stock here, let alone multiple visits. At least my friends enjoy finding shoes when I take them here...