I stopped by here a couple of Fridays ago with my wife and 3 other couples. Another couple in our party had made reservations before hand and when we arrived a couple of minutes after that time, we were immediately taken to our table. Whenever you first walk into Papa Js you immediately head past both their dessert case and bread making area. That is pure genius on their part as both their desserts and bread look good! Then to get to our table we also walked past a bar and up a flight of stairs. After that I didn't really see much else of the restaurant.
After our whole party had arrived and our waitress had taken all of our drink orders she came back up to our table and promised us that she would be back shortly as she had some desserts to take to a table. After about 15 minutes or so she finally did make it back to our table. For my dinner entree I decided on having the Romano chicken. It came out a short time later with a side of broccoli. The chicken had a nice golden color to its breading and tasted pretty good although a bit salty. I can take at least some credit for that though as I may have used the Parmesan that was on the table quite liberally. Meanwhile the broccoli was over cooked for my tastes and seemed mushy whenever I bit into it.
The bottom line for me is that I might stop by here again in the future. I wouldn't be the person to recommend it but I also wouldn't turn it down. I feel like the prices were fair for what you got and only wish that the service was a little better.