Got a personal "Nicola's New Favourite" but with ham instead of pepperoni and friend got the L'Italiana. Her's had a lot more feta than mine which I was a bit disappointed on but otherwise, it was a really delicious pizza. It had plenty of really fresh, flavourful basil which was a nice change from usual. We also split the garlic bread with cheese which was awesome and the cookies (cake-y and good but baked that morning rather than "fresh" which was also kind of disappointing). They were also out of the apple serenata when we asked for it because I guess they make them in large batches for the week rather than to order... and by Sunday night they were just out.
Salad, bread, cookies, and two pizzas for just over $32 before tip.
Service was pretty good though they seem disorganized about seating. It's not a huge place so that was odd.
Overall - good food and decent service so I would probably recommend. Still, not enough to top Oregano's or even NYPD.