Bar looks great and seems like an excellent addition to Madison's east side. Service was quick and responsive. The items off the regular menu were fine. I had the Seitan Philly (no cheese) and my sister-in-law the Tuna So Gouda. It was the special that was a total dud. My wife and brother both ordered the taco special, which they said was exceptionally bland. Unlike me, neither is inclined to tell the waitstaff that their food was blah when asked. The beer selection was excellent. I think they are on the right track, but need to find someone who will give them better feedback on new ideas for food. We will definitely come again, but not if we plan to have a pleasant conversation -- very, very loud with the tin ceiling (it looks great though).