This place is way overpriced. $3+ for a slice is ridiculous. Filling up the cups all the way with ice and then adding the soda? Cheap. Pies left out the whole day and reheated slices for 90 seconds? Not fresh.
BUT! The location is super convenient and there isn't really a competitive alternative close by. Just around the corner from Brickyard so great for Engineering students to grab a slice. Awesome selection of pies.
If you do go here, be very specific about what you want. "No ice" or "Very little ice" if you're getting a drink, "Make it crispy" if you want a crispy slice or "Don't overdo it" if you don't. The employees are really nice, but if you're picky about pizza (and price!) you might not enjoy this place that much. You're really paying for convenience over quality IMHO.