As one who doesn't like coffee, I feel bad even reviewing a coffee place, but in my defense they do serve non-coffee drinks. Consider this a review of the establishment and one particularly terrible Italian soda.
I really like the ambiance of this place. It seems quaint and cozy - not too busy. A good place to hang out. It was awkward that the front door hit another patron who was sitting in a lounge chair as I walked in. He seemed prepared for it so I assume this isn't the first time it has happened. There could probably be some light remodeling done to address this issue. The decor is otherwise is great. I enjoyed perusing the wall of business cards.
We ordered caramel Italian sodas. I figured they would be made with Torani syrup, but they actually just added caramel sauce to the drink instead. This caused it to bunch up on the bottom and not mix at all with the drink. First sip was all caramel chunks. The rest was tasteless. Before you criticize me for ordering an Italian Soda at a coffee joint, I'll say this: if you're going to have it on your menu, you should do it well.
Listen to other reviewers for opinions on the coffee here - I will be of no use. Take this to heart though: do not get the sodas.