Mr. Schnapp's is a goodie but an oldie. For a long time, as a vegetarian, I was really limited as they didn't have much for those on non-meat diets. Now, as a pescetarian I have more options, but I still go for the pizza at Mr. Schnapp's.
Monday night is order-in half-priced pizza. The pizza is phenomenal. I always make my own--pineapples, mushrooms, and green peppers.
The restaurant itself is very quiet, and a great place to have a leisurely dinner without having anyone prod you to leave.
I've heard good things about their other food from my family, but can't speak to that myself.