I finally got the chance to come back here years after those slices made an impression on me. And man, once again I was very impressed. I would say this is one of the best, if not THE best pizza in toronto. It ain't cheap (an extra large -- there is no large, just small, medium, XL -- will set you back to the tune of about $33-34) but its really good. They have a half dozen or so varieties. The extra large is an 18", and they will let you do half one way and half another. There are two types with goat cheese on them. both excellent. One has chicken and the other has sun dried tomato (among other things). the meat lovers variety is quite excellent too (with pepperoni, sausage and smoked bacon). They also have pretty high quality olive oil and balsamic vinegar on the tables to drizzle on when the food arrives.
I haven't tried anything other than pizza there, but I suspect its probably all good.