The previous reviews seem to be a mixed bag. I have probably been to this bar about 30 times over the past few years, and I have no idea who Shelley is (apparently the manager), and on that note I don't know people are interacting with her so much. Maybe it's just me but I go to bars to interact with my friends and other patrons, not the manager.
That all being said, the Wagon Wheel is a decent bar. It's a little small but has a nice heated patio during the winter. They also have a second bar downstairs "Bar 2" but it is rarely open. They've got a bunch of flat screens with sports on all the time. They also have a touch tunes jukebox, and touch screen bar video game station. Alcohol prices are very reasonable. I don't know if I've ever had their food, but when my friends get it, it looks like your average bar food. Nothing bad, but nothing amazing. It's a nice bar to grab a beer and watch a game.
Note: The crowd at this bar is usually a but older (40s), but not always. However, usually I'm the youngest person there (early 20s).