Yes, it really is excellent. This is high-quality gelato!
I went here with a friend who swore up and down that it was fantastic. When we showed up, the line was out the door to the curb, and I was still skeptical. When we got closer and saw all of the flavors, I became hopeful. And when I got my cup and started eating, I was happy. This is really good gelato.
I had the peanut butter crunch and salted caramel. The salted caramel was delicious, but the peanut butter crunch stole the show. This stuff is delicious! My friend had the dark chocolate (and when they say dark, they really mean dark!) and almond. Both of those flavors were delicious as well.
It's a little pricey for the amount, but high-quality gelato usually is.
I look forward to coming back and trying this place again--different flavors, of course.