After more than a year and a half this remains my favorite gelato place, bar none. Based on the lines I see here most of the time, I'm not alone! To their credit, they manage to move the line pretty quickly while still giving very good service.
Probably my only complaint is that their orange gelato is "seasonal", and so you can't get it all the time. Tonight it was gone (though they had "spicy chocolate", which really was spicy...burning the throat several seconds after swallowing). So tonight I got the limoncello. Good stuff!
They also have a gelato shake (which my daughter says is great), and a gelato cake (which I plan to try sometime!).
And on your birthday you get a free small (piccolo). Which is pretty cool.
I just keep coming back for more.