The food here is really good, the service is eh. But I am giving this 4 stars because the food really was just that good. The bread pudding was the best I've ever had and I don't LOVE bread pudding-- but I LOVED this one. Also, they make their own ice creams and their are delicious. The fish I had was extremely fresh. I am no food critic, but I did grow up on the East Coast beaches of NC, so I can say with certainty the fish is fresh. I love that they use local vendors for most of the food and the atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and hip.
My complaint, the service. Flighty is a word that comes to mind. The food took a really long time to come out and I have yet to figure out if that was the kitchen staff OR our waiter not putting our order in on time.
All that said, this is a place I will most certainly come back to.