Updating my review for Which Wich.
Yes, the prices are too high. Yes, it takes too long to get your sandwich. (This has nothing to do with the staff, by the way. It is entirely due to the slowest toaster oven in the industry). No, this will never be a great sandwich.
But the staff here really goes above and beyond what I'd expect from a restaurant at this price point, and I think that deserves an extra star.
(Also, their gyro was unexpectedly awesome. Too bad it was only a monthly special.)