Perhaps I was left a little more disappointed with this place after the high praise it's received from Yelp and people in my personal life, but man, did it make me sad. I wanted to love this place, from the moment I moved in. Alas, I don't think I will be returning.
The fruit and veg were nothing special (I don't eat organic) so there was no bonus to shop here. I bought english muffins that had clearly been frozen and thawed out, same with the cupcakes. I wound up throwing both out - and I loathe throwing out food.
One shining ray of hope that will bring me back to this store is that they have Hob Nobs. :) Huzzah!