Had dinner with a largeish group on a Friday night recently. Place is just as loud as the Magnus was but it was bearable.
Ambiance was fun, sort of Red Lobster + Taste.
The food was mixed with price not correlating to quality.
Shrimp cocktail was excellent.
We got a few of each variety of oysters not being very experienced oyster eaters. All were pretty good, some quite good but every one of them had bits of shell all over the edge of the shell so most of them had grit mixed in even after wiping the shell off myself. Only have had oysters a few times (including at The Magnus) and they always seemed cleaner shucked than this time
For the main course I had the 15$ fish and chips thinking I'd be stuffed from the other stuff and not want anything too fancy. It turned out to be the best part of the meal, I have not had such good fish fry anywhere! Frites were nice and dark, fish perfect and breading flavorful but not too greasy/heavy.
My wife had the lobster roll which was pretty good though her frites where white and undercooked. Others in our party had the whole red snapper and it was excellent as well.
So in general I'd say check the place out, but maybe not for the oysters.