The Dark and Stormy is the only way to fly, here. I don't care if you don't like rum. I don't like rum... but I love the Dark and Stormy.
This place is always packed. They distill their own liquor, and the hipsters, they come a-flocking. One of the female bartenders will ignore you if you're dressed like a normal person, but the other ones are cool enough.
Bear in mind you have to ASSERT yo'self at the bar to get service. This is a dog-eat-hipster olympic sport, and if you break eye contact, you lose.
Parking is pretty cut-throat too; be prepared to park on the street. Don't wear uncomfortable heels, ladies--there's the chance you won't get to park all that close.
PRO TIP: Get the drink that comes with a few servings in one beautiful tea-service style pitcher. Not because it's tasty (though it is, and very much so), but because you won't have to waste so much time fighting to get a drink at the bar as often. ;)