I've been here for dinner and had a FANTASTIC meal. It was phenomenal and during happy hour. So you really can't beat the price.
My dinner experience here was so good, I wanted to take my cousin here for lunch since it'll be her last time visiting Madison.
Lunch here was... horrible. There was one waiter and one chef/cook. There were two other tables, three including mine. We ordered three buns, the lobster bisque, and three entrees. It took about 45 minutes for our buns and bisque to come out. It took about an hour and thirty minutes for our entrees to come out. And I know the exact times because we got there at around one and I was starving. So every minute passing was excruciating. (And our two hour parking ticket told us what time we arrived). The lobster bisque is good. Creamy without it tasting too much like heavy whipping cream. The duck confit bun was just horrible. And I rarely use that word to describe food because I love food. But it really was bad. The duck didn't taste like duck, it just tasted like fried rock salt. My lips were burning from the saltiness.
The food here is really good. But don't come during lunch time. Also their house iced tea, which they advertise as their own house blend, is just Lipton iced tea. Discovering this just soured my lunch experience here.