This was my second visit to Hy's in as many years. On this occasion, as on the first, my impression was... meh. The restaurant itself is quite nice, what you would expect from a traditional, high end, steak house.
I had the New York, rare. It came rare, which is great. It also came with the fat cap completely untouched. I mean, not even an attempt at a sear; not the way to cook a New York in my opinion. The waiter suggested this was how they were always cooked. I've cooked (and eaten) my fair share of New Yorks - I'm not sure I recall ever getting a New York with the fat cap completely untouched.
The waiter also served us a bottle of wine a vintage year off of what we ordered and said absolutely nothing about it (he also dripped wine on the table on every pour he made).