i think there are some pizza snobs reviewing this place or something, gus's is BOMB!
they used to have a deal here, the dorm room special (woa, not THAT special...) it was an amazing deal that enabled me to survive college. the dorm room special was an 18" one topping with two 32oz drinks for about $10. WHAAAAAAT? how can you pass that up? and in my honest opinion, i thought it tasted really good.
it's greasy, so if you're a pansy just pass-on. pass, pansy... pass...
the inside can be pretty dirty too, but it's not like you'd come in here suit and tie now! again some honesty here... i have seen a rat running around inside... i calmly told the workers, and they were a little less calm about it than i was haha. never stopped me from coming back again and again though. guess i felt the rat added the true NY character to the joint.
late night crowd can be a little interesting... a mix of really drunk kids and some ghetto characters just hanging out. maybe an occasional hooker too... trying to lure the drunks.