I've been a repeat customer of this place for a year now since they opened and the quality has been consistent, or even better. I very much agree with the positive reviews here, especially the one which mentioned that this place gets everything right when others would miss out on one element that would make it the perfect pie. I understand taste is very relative (hence some negative reviews here) but Rockaway's for me has the perfect crust flavor and texture, the freshest cheese, high-quality ingredients, and it's all seasoned just right... and I'm even more pleased with the new flavors they have. I've tried many hyped-up pizza places in Pittsburgh before and (as my bf worded it), "other pizzas make me appreciate Rockaway's more". I personally wouldn't allow myself to have any other pizza for cheat day. So hard to resist getting it all the time since it's only 10 mins away from me.
For recommendations: if you like white sauce, get The Artichoke. If you like sweet+salty combo get The Honey Pie. For an overall indulgent and rich, cheesy treat, get The Lasagna and add bacon to it (you're welcome).