The pizza was pretty good, but I don't think I would name it the best. I went this evening (Friday night) and arrived slightly before the main dinner crowd. Quick seating and good service.
We had the small house salad, and it was good. Really, I don't like ordering or eating salad. Not my favorite thing. I always hear Pee Wee Herman in my head saying "MMMM Salady". But it was good as far as salads go.
We ordered the large pizza with mushroom and pepperoni. It's a thin crust pizza and was good for thin crust. Good tomato, basil and other herbs. The pizza itself was about $15. I thought the ingredients were maybe a touch pricey. Basically $2 per ingredient unless you ordered artichoke, red peppers or sun tried tomatoes - those were $4. The price could rise quickly depending on the toppings.
The flavor was good and I did put down 2 pieces, but the bottom was a bit too well done for me. The black bottom changed the overall flavor, but still good. I did enjoy the decor and small subway signs around the bar.
Comfortable atmosphere, good service and good pizza. I will be back.