I went there with three others on a Thursday morning for breakfast. The place was fairly full, but we had no problem finding a seat. For how full it was, we were able to get our order in and our food served to us pretty fast. Service was great.
I ordered the sausage and cheese omelete, hashbrowns and toast. My boyfriend ordered french toast and bacon. My mother ordered pancakes and hashbrowns. And my sister ordered hashbrowns and toast. My mom ordered two pancakes without knowing how humungous they make them (size of a dinner plate), so the second pancake was consumed family style and everyone got to try it. The problem with giant pancakes like that is they are often cooked unevenly and some parts are burnt. No, not this one. It was perfect and tasted great. Aside from the pancake, everyone also loved what they got.
The bill for four people came to $33.
The only downside is the atmosphere. Wood paneling walls to video poker; it's just your standard older Wisconsin bar. But this was minor to me. It kind of has its charm in an odd way. It's so minor that I'll still give Brothers Three 5 stars.