For a pizzeria in Ohio this place is sure to be at the top of the heap compared to other pizzeria's / Italian restaurants in that fine state. HOWEVER being that I have lived in New York for many years -read access to some of the best Italian food anywhere . . . I was not impressed in the least. The sauce reminded me too much of sauce from a jar -also onions have no place in a plain cheese pie. The kids liked it, but then again most kids also like Chef Boyardee.
Sorry but when I go out of my way to try an establishment that was recommended on Diner's Drive-In's and Dives I expect something spectacular like 'Melt' instead of just average and edible.
If you are not going out of your way to go there then fine, otherwise do not waste your time.